This is probably the best ghost story I have ever read, and quite possibly even the best horror (though there are some other strong contenders). What helps this short novel by Shirley Jackson really stand out (and send shivers down its readers’ spines) is that it genuinely feels the most realistic of any horror novel that I’ve read before.
Of course, realism is hard to do when dealing with anything supernatural, but she’s done a fantastic job here. The story goes that a man called Dr. John Montague invites a group of people to stay with him in a place called Hill House because it is allegedly one of the most haunted houses in America and he wants to bring them together in order to document their experiences and potentially find evidence for the existence of ghosts. A pretty plausible setup.
The kinds of frightening things that end up happening are extremely minor – doors seeming to slam shut on their own and so forth, but I think this actually really helps it. When you read other novels that have unfathomable monsters chasing after people, you really can’t fathom how something like that would feel, because it’s not rooted in reality. Meanwhile, almost most all of us have had the experience of something weird, or slightly unsettling happening that we can’t properly explain. The fear and anxiety they feel is very relatable.
Meanwhile, not only are all the characters masterfully written (especially Eleanor, who is essentially the main character) and compelling, but their reactions to the inexplicable events feel completely natural, with them often making jokes in the face of the unexplained as they try and dismiss what’s happening as ridiculous, and later even question themselves about what they’ve experienced. For a lot of what happens a “rational” possibility is given, and a lot of it makes you start to question the characters’ sanity, in much the same way that you’d do so with yourself if you kept having ghostly experiences.
At the end of novel, I wondered whether it was really about a haunted house at all, but I loved how things weren’t spelled out directly one way or another. It was Eleanor and Theodora at the heart of it that I felt most invested in, and their strangely intense and uncomfortable relationship helped compliment the horror perfectly, as there were social tensions alongside the supernatural ones. Ultimately, it all comes together brilliantly, and reflects Shirley Jackon’s perfect understanding of human minds and feelings.
Rating: 9.2/10
Buy it here.